“An absolutely worthy winner. … Haldane makes the reader feel as if they've been dropped into the daily lives of those living in 1869-era Victoria, and refuses to shy away from the truth in favor of a more politically correct approach to historical fiction.”──Sarah Weinman, National Post (Canada)
“Haldane's first mystery, evocative and elegantly written, is a deeply philosophical look at a relatively unknown historical period.”──Kirkus Reviews
“Poet, publisher, and psychologist Haldane (Emotional First Aid) makes his fiction debut with an exceptional historical set on Vancouver Island, with this winner of Canada's Arthur Ellis Award for best novel... A host of intriguing characters combine with Haldane's firm grasp of the period to make this an enthralling read.”──Publishers Weekly
“Haldane never shies away from period-specific language and attitudes, which make readers feel as though they are walking the dirty streets of Victoria by his side. Historical whodunit fans will relish this exciting trip to 19th-century frontier Canada.”──Library Journal
“A strong crime fiction debut with an interesting multicultural element.”──Historical Novel Society
“This singular story offers a lively, up-close look at Victorian manners and views of that time, set in the context of cold-blooded murder. ... Haldane gets under the skin of his characters, stripping away the civilized veneer to reveal the inner thoughts and desires of each individual, often at great odds with their public facades.”──Bookpage